Gulf Education and Social Policy Review

Published date: Feb 20 2025

Journal Title: Gulf Education and Social Policy Review

Issue title: Gulf Education and Social Policy Review (GESPR): Volume 6, Issue 1

Pages: 63 - 83

DOI: 10.18502/gespr.v6i1.16887

Sherine Al Shallahs.alshallah@unsw.edu.auUNSW Sydney, Sydney

To understand the extent to which the intangible cultural heritage of stateless communities in Gulf countries is safeguarded under the law, it is necessary to interpret international, regional, and state frameworks around cultural heritage and cultural rights – or human rights to culture. The current study reviews international law and regional frameworks that govern intangible cultural heritage in Gulf countries and examines a case study of the Bidun community in Kuwait.  The article focuses on intangible cultural heritage in the context of stateless communities and examines the relationship to tangible cultural heritage as part of the intangible cultural heritage.  The study finds that while the legal framework in Gulf countries lays out the groundwork for safeguarding the intangible cultural heritage of stateless communities, some states’ laws and policies are not aligned with obligations under international and regional frameworks.

Keywords: Stateless, Cultural heritage, Tangible cultural heritage, Intangible cultural heritage, Gulf heritage, Bidun

[1] Ahrén, M. (2008). Protecting peoples’ cultural rights: A question of properly understanding the notion of states and nations? In F. Francioni & M. Scheinin (Eds.), Cultural human rights (pp. 91–118). Brill Nijhoff.

[2] Al Shallah, S. (2024). Refugee protection through safeguarding intangible cultural heritage of the home country and refugee journey. International Journal of Cultural Property, 30(3), 280–297.

[3] Al Shammari, A. (2019, December 2). The rise of Bidun literature: Representation and advocacy in Kuwait. The Arab Gulf States Institute in Washington.

[4] Al-Dhafiri, N. ( .( 2015 كاليسكا [Kaliska]. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/27465626

[5] Alrabei, T. (2023). Stateless literature of the Gulf. Bloomsbury Publishing. https://www.bloomsbury. com/ca/stateless-literature-of-the-gulf-9780755644889/

[6] Bagaric, M., & McConvill, J. (2006). Refugee law: Moving to a more humane approach – Ignoring the framers’ intentions. Journal of Migration and Refugee Issues, 2(3).

[7] Beaugrand, C. (2014, November 28). Urban margins in Kuwait and Bahrain: Decay, dispossession and politicization. Roundtable on Arabian Peninsulas, 18, 735–745.

[8] Beaugrand, C. (2020, December 23). The absurd injunction to not belong and the Bidūn in Kuwait. Cambridge University Press.

[9] Bedoon Cultural Week. (n.d.). Home [YouTube channel]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/channel/ UCqdMlgHo7RANbxCR99zQaCA?app=desktop

[10] Blake, J. (2000). On defining the cultural heritage. The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 49(1), 61–63.

[11] Blake, J. (2017). Protection of intangible cultural heritage in the event of armed conflict: An imperative for cultural heritage, humanitarian and human rights law. Europa Ethnica, 74(3/4), 73–81.

[12] Burkett, I. (2001). Traversing the swampy terrain of postmodern communities: Towards theoretical revisionings of community development. European Journal of Social Work, 4(3), 233–246.

[13] Chechi, A. (2016). Migrants’ cultural rights at the confluence of international human rights law and international cultural heritage law. International Human Rights Law Review, 5(1), 26-59. https://doi.org/ 10.1163/22131035-00501001

[14] Constitute.org. (2022, April 27). The Constitution of Kuwait 1962, Reinstated 1992. https://www. constituteproject.org/constitution/Kuwait_1992.pdf

[15] Decolonising Architecture Art Research. (n.d.). IV. Conservation. Refugee Heritage. https://www. decolonizing.ps/site/iv-conservation/

[16] Francioni, F. (2011). The human dimension of international cultural heritage law: An introduction. European Journal of International Law, 22(1), 9.

[17] Francioni, F. (2011). The human dimension of international cultural heritage law: An introduction. European Journal of International Law, 22(1), 9.

[18] Fraser, N. (2003). Social justice in the age of identity politics: Redistribution, recognition and participation. In N. Fraser & A. Honneth (Eds.), Redistribution or recognition? A political philosophical exchange. Verso.

[19] Fraser, N. (2008). Rethinking recognition: Overcoming displacement and reification in cultural politics. In K. Olsen (Ed.), Adding insult to injury: Nancy Fraser debates her critics (pp. 129, 135). Verso.

[20] Frigo, M. (2004). Cultural property v. cultural heritage: A ”battle of concepts” in international law? International Review of the Red Cross, 86(854), 367–376.

[21] Gill, G. (1984). The refugee in international law. Oxford University Press.

[22] Government of Kuwait. (n.d.). Kuwait national development plan 2020–2025. https://media.gov.kw/ assets/img/Ommah22_Awareness/PDF/NewKuwait/Revised%20KNDP%20-%20EN.pdf

[23] Harrison, R. (2013). Heritage: Critical approaches. Routledge.

[24] Hill, E., Craith, M. N., & Clopot, C. (2018). At the limits of cultural heritage rights? The Glasgow Bajuni Campaign and the UK immigration system: A case study. International Journal of Cultural Property, 25(1), 35–58.

[25] Hochberg, G. (2020). From heritage to refugee heritage: Notes on temporality, memory, and space. Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East, 40(1), 43.

[26] Human Rights Committee. (1999). General Comment 27: Freedom of movement (Art. 12) - General comments of the Human Rights Committee on article 12.4 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, UN Doc CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.9.

[27] Human Rights Council. (2016, February 3). General report of the Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights: Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (31st session, Agenda Item 3, UN Doc A/HRC/31/59), 20.

[28] Human Rights Council. (2022, January 31). Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development (49th session, Agenda item 3, UN Doc A/HRC/49/54, Advance unedited version).

[29] Human Rights Watch. (1994, December 1). Azerbaijan: Seven years of conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh. https://www.hrw.org/report/1994/12/01/seven-years-conflict-nagorno-karabakh

[30] Human Rights Watch. (2011, June 13). Prisoners of the past: Kuwaiti Bidun and the burden of statelessness. https://www.hrw.org/report/2011/06/13/prisoners-past/kuwaiti-bidun-and-burden-statelessness

[31] Human Rights Watch. (n.d.). World report 2023: Kuwait. https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2023/ country-chapters/kuwait.

[32] International Criminal Court, The Office of The Prosecutor. (2021). Policy on cultural heritage. https: //www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/itemsDocuments/20210614-otp-policy-cultural-heritage-eng.pdf

[33] International Justice Resource Center. (n.d.). Middle East and North Africa. https://ijrcenter.org/regional/ middle-east-and-north-africa/

[34] Kareem, M. (2014). Dying like a statue. https://www.poetryinternational.com/en/poets-poems/poems/ poem/103-291813_DYING-LIKE-A-STATUE

[35] Kareem, M. (2021, June 2). Bidoon: A cause and its literature are born. Heinrich Boll Stiftung. https://www.boell.de/en/2021/06/02/bidoon-geburt-einer-literatur-und-eines-politischen-anliegens

[36] Kareem, M. (2022, May 27). The migrant poet slaughters his voice. Four poems (Mona Kareem Blogspot).

[37] Kuutma, K. (2013). Between arbitration and engineering: concepts and contingencies in the shaping of heritage regimes. In R. Bendix, A. Eggert, & A. Peselmann (Eds.), Heritage regimes and the state (pp. 21–36). Universitätsverlag Göttingen.

[38] Kuwait Government Online. (n.d.). Customs and traditions in Kuwait. https://e.gov.kw/sites/kgoenglish/ Pages/Visitors/AboutKuwait/CultureAndHeritageCustomsAndTraditions.aspx

[39] League of Arab States. (n.d.). Member states. http://www.lasportal.org/ar/aboutlas/Pages/CountryData. aspx

[40] Lemkin, R. (1933). Acts constituting a general (transnational) danger considered as offences against the law of nations. 5th Conference for the Unification of Penal Law in Madrid. http://perma.cc/62QS-MR5G.

[41] Lister, R. (2008). (Mis)recognition, social inequality and social justice: A critical social policy perspective. In T. Lovell (Ed.), (Mis)recognition, social inequality and social justice (pp. 157, 169). Routledge.

[42] Lixinski, L. (2019). International heritage law for communities: Exclusion and re-imagination (chapter 1). Oxford University Press.

[43] Logan, W. (2009). Playing the devil’s advocate: Protecting intangible cultural heritage and the infringement of human rights. Historic Environment, 22(3), 14–18.

[44] Minority Rights Group. (n.d.). Bidoon in Kuwait. https://minorityrights.org/minorities/bidoon/

[45] National Council for Culture, Arts and Literature. (n.d.). The strategic plan for improving the performance of the National Council for Culture, Arts and Literature 2015/2020.https://www.nccal.gov.kw/Content/Images/uploaded/الخطة%20الأستراتيجية/الخطة%20انجليزي.pdf

[46] Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. (n.d.). Member states. https://www.oic-oci.org/states/?lan=en

[47] Pan American Union. (1934, December 26). Convention on Rights and Duties of States adopted by the Seventh International Conference of American States (Art. 1).

[48] Turki, K. (2017). ثلاثة من الشمال [Three from the north]. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36637541

[49] UDHR arts 18, 26–27; ICCPR arts. 18–19; ICESCR arts. 13, 15; Human Rights Council, Report of the independent expert in the field of cultural rights, Ms. Farida Shaheed, submitted pursuant to resolution 10/23, UN Doc A/HRC/14/36 (2010, March 22); ICC (n9) 10–11; See also Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1577 UNTS 3 (1989) arts. 28–29 (CRC); Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, opened for signature 1950, November 4, 213 UNTS 221 (entered into force 1953, September 3) arts. 9–10 (European Convention); Protocol to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, opened for signature 1952, March 20, ETS No 9 (entered into force 1954, May 18) arts. 1–2; Organization of American States, American Convention on Human Rights opened for signature 1969, November 22 (entered into force 1978, July 18), arts. 12–13, 26.

[50] UN General Assembly. (1965, December 21). International convention on the elimination of all forms of racial discrimination (Art. 1). https://www.ohchr.org/en/instrumentsmechanisms/ instruments/international-convention-elimination-all-forms-racial

[51] UN General Assembly. (1966, December 16). International covenant on economic, social and cultural rights (Art. 27). https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-covenanteconomic- social-and-cultural-rights

[52] UN General Assembly. (1979, December 18). Convention on the elimination of all forms of discrimination against women, UN Doc A/RES/34/180 (34th session, 1979–1980) art. 13(c).

[53] UN General Assembly. (1981, November 25). Declaration on the elimination of all forms of intolerance and of discrimination based on religion and belief (36th session, A/RES/36/55 art 1).

[54] UN General Assembly. (1981, November 25). Declaration on the elimination of all forms of intolerance and of discrimination (Art. 1). https://www.ohchr.org/en/instrumentsmechanisms/ instruments/declaration-elimination-all-forms-intolerance-and-discrimination

[55] UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, & League of Arab States. (2004). Arab charter on human rights. https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/551368?ln=en

[56] UNESCO. (2001, November 2). UNESCO universal declaration on cultural diversity (art. 7). https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/unesco-universal-declaration-cultural-diversity

[57] UNESCO. (2003). Convention for the safeguarding of the intangible cultural heritage. https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/convention-safeguarding-intangible-culturalheritage? TSPD_101_R0=080713870fab200039086905db4ef7be88a0e140a365be28de6dd2d60c 30c12ceb792b0b599defd508e6b137aa14300024e3ac3b8b34cf3cb05841f649ce871a1c03d6379210 776d2561292a9cfef94ea9f7e4b2b8d8ab02e2db2b031c0903c5#item-2.

[58] UNESCO. (n.d.). Cairo declaration on human rights in Islam. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/ pf0000096129.

[59] UNESCO. (n.d.). Lists of intangible cultural heritage and the register of good safeguarding practices. https://ich.unesco.org/en/lists?text=®ion%5b%5d=03&multinational=3#tabs.

[60] UNHCR. (n.d.). About statelessness. https://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/about-statelessness/

[61] UNHCR. (n.d.). Arab declaration on “Belonging and Legal Identity” – Under the patronage of His Excellency President of the Republic of Tunisia. https://www.unhcr.org/eg/wpcontent/ uploads/sites/36/2021/06/Final-Ministerial-Conference-Declaration-on-Belonging-and- Identity-English.pdf

[62] United Nations Economic and Social Council Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. (2009, November 2–20). General comment 21: Right of everyone to take part in cultural life (art. 15, para. 1(a) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights), UN Doc E/C.12/GC/21 21 (43rd session) 2.

[63] United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation, UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity, (31st session, General Conference of UNESCO, 2 November 2001), Preamble.

[64] United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation. (2001, November 2). UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity (31st session, General Conference of UNESCO) art 7.

[65] United Nations Human Rights Treaty Bodies. (n.d.). UN treaty body database. https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/15/TreatyBodyExternal/Treaty.aspx?CountryID=13&Lang=en

[66] United Nations. (2022, September 29). UN Child Rights Committee publishes findings on Germany, Kuwait, North Macedonia, Philippines, South Sudan, Ukraine, Uzbekistan and Vietnam. https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/09/un-child-rights-committee-publishes-findingsgermany- kuwait-north-macedonia

[67] van Waas, L. (2010). The situation of stateless persons in the Middle East and North Africa. UNHCR. https://www.unhcr.org/media/situation-stateless-persons-middle-east-and-north-africa-laura-van-waas

[68] Waterton, E., & Smith, L. (2010). The recognition and misrecognition of community heritage. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 16(1–2), 4–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527250903441671

[69] Yar, M. (2002). Community in absentia? Res Publica, 8, 179–198.